Flipping channels the other night, we caught a couple of minutes of a History Channel program about the Jonestown tragedy. I don’t remember it being in the news because I was very small when it happened, so I figured out what it was through second hand information I have heard over the years. Specifically, when the Waco siege took place, people kept referring to Jonestown.
It made me start thinking a little about communes, particularly since Warren Jeffs and his sect have been in the news quite a bit the past couple of years.
High profile communes nowadays tend to be religious, extreme, and potentially involved in illicit and/or illegal activity.
Communes kind of have a bad rep. Yet, they are also steeped in a certain amount of romanticism. When we think of communes, maybe we think of the 60s. Or maybe we just think of collective farms back in the days of the Soviet Union. Actually, I am not too sure what we think of. These are my associations.
I have been thinking that there are some very simple, practical reasons that communes are not the social arrangements most people want to live in:
1) We may have forgotten how it feels to have extended family clustered around us, piling generations upon generations, but it couldn’t have been too good. It was *economically expedient* in the past, but as soon as couples could afford to set up their own households, they did, even if it was a stone’s throw down the road. Our current modern thought suggests that there are some problems with the nuclear family in the United States, but there are also legitimate reasons that this has become such a popular social structure. Family, oh family. There is really so much that can be said about family.
2) The more people, the more mess you have. You need a very organized division of labor to run a commune. Or a few extremely patient people.
3) Principles and opinions. Even the best-intentioned commune can only survive a limited amount of dissent. Throw a bunch of mostly-agreeable, mostly-agreeing people together in a room and see how long it takes before you have a disagreement. If nothing else, personalities will chafe and heads will eventually butt.